二、PSD的诊断
目前,国内外关于PSD研究的文献,除了部分使用的是DSM-4中抑郁症的诊断标准外,有些仅仅依靠症状量表作为PSD 的诊断标准。Cumming 等[22]对DSM-4 中症状标准进行研究发现,PSD 和抑郁症组反应快感缺失的感觉缺乏存在显著差异;Spalletta等[23]发现自罪自责症状对两组患者的诊断效力不足。一项PSD 和原发性抑郁临床特征比较的研究发现,PSD 患者中迟缓/精神运动性迟滞多见,而原发性抑郁患者有更多的快感缺失、悲观、自杀想法和更严重的注意力集中障碍[24]。Gainotti 等[15]的研究显示,PSD患者比原发性抑郁患者更可能出现灾难性反应、激越和情绪波动。此外,Robinson 等[25]将PSD 分为轻、重两型。轻型PSD的诊断标准为DSM-3中恶劣心境的诊断标准,重型PSD 的诊断标准为抑郁症的诊断标准。由上可知,对于PSD 诊断需注意以下问题:首先,抑郁症中症状学标准,如能力下降、体重减轻、哭泣(病例性哭泣)等症状,可能是由脑卒中所致,脑卒中所致的神经功能缺损症状,可能对PSD 有一定混杂作用;其次,一些症状,如容易疲乏、淡漠等,可能为脑卒中后疲乏、卒中后淡漠等并发症,而非PSD症状,即如何科学准确地进行不同并发症之间的鉴别诊断极为重要;再次,PSD 患者可能有不同抑郁症的核心症状群,应在该特异症状基础上建立PSD 的诊断。因此,规范PSD 的诊断标准对于科研和临床工作极为重要。
目前,我们正在开发面部表情识别系统,通过多维度的表情识别,辨别患者是否存在情绪低落、负性情绪偏向等抑郁症的核心症状,其客观性和有效性已经广泛得到了国外研究的证实[26]。该系统基于大量临床数据,结合专家经验知识,可成为较为规范的诊断辅助手段,对PSD 的诊断将起到重要的参考作用。同时,基于统计模型的计算机自动情绪分析,避免了医师主观偏倚的弊端,具备客观性。表情识别系统自动采集视频,语音等数据,不需要患者配合,不干扰正常治疗和休养,设备无侵入性。表情识别系统可持续工作,获得的诊断数据能更好地反映病情的发展变化,具备连续性[27]。在PSD的研究过程中,积极引入以上辅助检查手段,将为PSD诊断标准基础上逐步引入客观指标提供研究依据。
综上所述,PSD 的评估工具多种多样,寻找反映疾病特异性的、科学有效的、广泛公认的评估工具,规范PSD的诊断标准是探讨疾病的流行病学特征、发病机制、预防和治疗的基石,并将极大推进PSD 的临床诊治工作。
参考文献
[1]Hackett ML,Yapa C,Parag V,et al.Frequency of depression after stroke:a systematic review of observational studies[J].Stroke,2005,36(6):1330-1340.
[2]Ferro JM,Caeiro L,Santos C.Poststroke emotional and behavior impairment:a narrative review[J].J Cerebrovasc Dis,2009,27(Suppl 1):197-203.
[3]Astrom M,Adolfsson R,Asplund K.Major depression in stroke patients A 3-year longitudinal study[J].Stroke,1993,24(7):976-982.
[4]Pedersen PM,Jorgensen HS,Nakayama H,et al.Aphasia in acute stroke:incidence,determinants,and recovery[J].Ann Neurol,1995,38(4):659-666.
[5]Engelter ST,Gostynski M,Papa S,et al.Epidemiology of aphasia attributable to first ischemic stroke:incidence,severity,fluency,etiology,and thrombolysis[J].Stroke,2006,37(6):1379-1384.
[6]Zung WW.A self-rating depression scale[J].Arch Gen Psychiatry,1965,12(1):63-70.
[7]Beck AT,Ward CH,Mendelson M,et al.An inventory for measuring depression[J].Arch Gen Psychiatry,1961,4(6):561-571.
[8]Williams LS,Brizendine EJ,Plue L,et al.Performance of the PHQ-9 as a screening tool for depression after stroke[J].Stroke,2005,36(3):635-638.
[9]Radloff LS.The CES-D scale:A Self-Report Depression Scale for Research in the General Population[J].Applied Psychological Measurement,1977,1(3):385-401.
[10]Snaith RP,Zigmond AS.The hospital anxiety and depression scale[J].Br Med J(Clin Res Ed),1986,292(6516):344.
[11]Rush AJ,Trivedi MH,Ibrahim HM,et al.The 16-Item Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology(QIDS),clinician rating(QIDS-C),and self-report(QIDS-SR):a psychometric evaluation in patients with chronic major depression[J].Biol psychiatry,2003,54(5):573-583.
[12]Yue Y,Liu R,Lu J,et al.Reliability and validity of a new post-strokedepression scale in chinese population[J].J Affect Disorders,2014,174c:317-323.(https://www.daowen.com)
[13]Hamilton M.A rating scale for depression[J].J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry,1960,23(1):56-62.
[14]Montgomery SA,Asberg M.A new depression scale designed to be sensitive to change[J].Br J Psychiatry,1979,134(4):382-389.
[15]Gainotti G,Azzoni A,Razzano C,et al.The Post-Stroke Depression Rating Scale:a test specifically devised to investigate affective disorders of stroke patients[J].J Clin Exp Neuropsychol,1997,19(3):340-356.
[16]Khan A,Brodhead AE,Kolts RL.Relative sensitivity of the Montgomery Asberg depression rating scale,the Hamilton depression rating scale and the Clinical Global Impressions rating scale in antidepressant clinical trials:a replication analysis[J].Int Clin Psychopharmacol,2004,19(3):157-160.
[17]Arruda JE,Stern RA,Somerville JA.Measurement of mood states in stroke patients:validation of the visual analog mood scales[J].Arch Phys Med Rehabil,1999,80(6):676-680.
[18]Turner-Stokes L,Kalmus M,Hirani D,et al.The Depression Intensity Scale Circles(DISCs):a first evaluation of a simple assessment tool for depression in the context of brain injury[J].J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry,2005,76(9):1273-1278.
[19]Benaim C,Cailly B,Perennou D,et al.Validation of the aphasic depression rating scale[J].Stroke,2004,35(7):1692-1696.
[20]Sutcliffe LM,Lincoln NB.The assessment of depression in aphasic stroke patients:the development of the Stroke Aphasic Depression Questionnaire[J].Clin Rehabil,1998,12(6):506-513.
[21]de Man-van Ginkel JM,Hafsteinsdottir TB,Lindeman E,et al.Inhospital risk prediction for post-stroke depression:Development and Validation of the Post-stroke Depression Prediction Scale[J].Stroke,2013,44(9):2441-2445.
[22]Cumming TB,Churilov L,Skoog I,et al.Little evidence for different phenomenology in poststroke depression[J].Acta psychiatr Scand,2010,121(6):424-430.
[23]Spalletta G,Ripa A,Caltagirone C.Symptom profile of DSM-IV major and minor depressive disorders in first - ever stroke patients[J].Am J Geriatr Psychiatry,2005,13(2):108-115.
[24]Lipsey JR,Spencer WC,Rabins PV,et al.Phenomenological comparison of poststroke depression and functional depression[J].Am J Psychiatry,1986,143(4):527-529.
[25]Robinson RG,Starr LB,Kubos KL,et al.A two-year longitudinal study of post-stroke mood disorders:findings during the initial evaluation[J].Stroke,1983,14(5):736-741.
[26]Reed LI,Sayette MA,Cohn JF.Impact of depression on response to comedy:a dynamic facial coding analysis[J].J Abnorm Psychol,2007,116(4):804-809.
[27]Huang KQ,Wu Z,Wang Q.Image enhancement based on the statistics of visual representation[J].Image and Vision Computing,2005,23(1):51-57.
(袁勇贵)